The Outer Banks (OBX) on North Carolina’s coast is well-known for its stunning beaches, dunes, public parks, lighthouses, and shipwreck sites. So, it’s understandable why the countless options for the best pizza in Nags Head can sometimes go unnoticed. Regardless of how you slice it, choosing the best pizza restaurant can be tough, especially when you’re unfamiliar with the area.
You might be wondering which local favorites are worth the trek. Going home and freshening up for supper after a fishing excursion or a pleasant beach day isn’t always worth the effort. If you’re on vacation, the last thing you want to stress about is where to eat. That’s why we’ve put together a list of the best pizza in Nags Head to satisfy everyone’s cravings.
Nags Head Pizza Company
Nags Head Pizza Company serves a wide range of classic and gourmet pizzas that will make the entire family happy. From traditional hand-tossed pies to pesto pizza with gluten-free dough and vegan cheese, Nags Head Pizza Company intends to provide a delicious dinner for every diet and everyone. Undecided? Make it a halfer!
One also can’t go wrong with the salads, each with its own handmade dressing and protein selections. And don’t skip dessert!
With pick-up, delivery, or outdoor waterfront seating at your fingertips, they help bring dining at a family-friendly location at an accessible price to Nags Head, North Carolina.
Address: 7531 South Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head, NC 27959
Hours: Sunday – Thursday 4 pm-8 pm, Friday and Saturday 4 pm – 9 pm
Slice Pizzeria
Since 2008, Slice Pizzeria in Kill Devil Hills has provided hand-crafted pizzas to the Outer Banks. It’s been chosen as the greatest pizza place in the region several times.
Providing a full Italian menu, including spaghetti, calzones, and sandwiches, in addition to their delicious pizza, Slice Pizzeria offers indoor and outdoor dining (weather permitting). Takeout and delivery are also available.
Address: 710 South Croatan Highway, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948
Hours: Open Wednesday – Monday 12 pm – 8 pm
Black Pelican
The Black Pelican was one of the Outer Banks’ first year-round eateries. The one-of-a-kind structure built in 1874 served as a United States Lifesaving Station. It’s since become one of the go-to locales for Outer Banks Pizza.
This oceanfront restaurant features pleasant dining rooms, an outdoor deck, and a full bar that exudes personality alongside rustic appeal. Take a walk through maritime history while enjoying panoramic ocean views.
Appetizers like Hatteras Clam Chowder and calamari are on the menu, while everything from fresh seafood, steaks, gumbo, vegetarian selections, sandwiches, and wood-fired pizzas dominate lunch and dinner.
Address: 3848 Virginia Dare Trail, North Kitty Hawk, NC 27949
Hours: Open Tuesday – Sunday 11:30 am – 9 pm, Closed Mondays
Pizzazz Pizza
Pizzazz Pizza has been serving the OBX for almost thirty years. The local family-owned and operated pizza restaurant serves standard, though delicious fares, like pizza, chicken wings, and subs.
With convenient locations in Nags Head, Duck, Corolla, and Grandy, you can enjoy their excellent pizza wherever you are vacationing, from the Southern Shores to Roanoke Island.
Address: 2512 South Croatan Hwy, Nags Head, NC 27959
Hours: Monday – Sunday 11:30 am-9:30 pm
American Pie
If you’re looking for a casual, quick meal on the Outer Banks, go no farther than American Pie Pizza and Homemade Ice Cream. Add a side of hand-crafted ice cream to your pizza picnic, and you’ve got yourself the quintessential North Carolina beach drive-in!
Address: 1600 South Virginia Dare Trail, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948
Hours: Open every day 11 am – 10 pm
Lucky 12 Tavern
You’ll be wowed by the variety of options available at the Lucky 12 Tavern, whether you’re there for the cuisine, craft beers, sports, or all of the above!
Local seafood and fruit, hand-patted burgers, New York-style pizza, Philly cheesesteaks, the freshest salads, outstanding chicken wings, and delectable fries are just a few of the items on the cheap evening menu. Both dine-in and takeout are available.
Address: 3308 South Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head, NC 27959
Hours: Monday – Saturday 11:30 am-midnight
Village Pizza
Village Pizza, a locally owned and run restaurant in the Village at Nags Head, is located next to the huge yellow Oceans shop (next to Sonic). This pizzeria serves excellent New York-style pizza.
Choose from a variety of toppings to build your own great pizza or order one of their specialty pies, like the Sea Harvest of Buffalo Chicken. Garlic knots, giant wings in various flavors, sandwiches and subs, fries, and salads with house-made dressings are also available.
This restaurant is exclusively open for takeout.
Address: 5205 South Croatan Highway, Nags Head, NC 27959
Hours: Tuesday – Thursday 11 am – 2:30 pm, Friday 11 am – 7:30 pm, Saturday 3:30 pm – 7:30 pm, Closed Sunday & Monday
Yellow Submarine Pizza & Subs
This Beatles-themed pizza parlor is famed for its excellent Nags Head pizza. So whether you want one of Yellow Submarine’s specialty pizzas, like the Philly Cheesesteak or West Coast white, or simply wanting to build your own pizza, you can’t go wrong.
Perhaps you’re in the mood for something else, like a calzone, a Stromboli, or an oven-baked sub like the legendary Italian Grinder? Yellow Submarine Pizza & Subs is sure to deliver, which they do…literally!
Don’t forget to add a special touch to that delivery order. Yellow Submarine’s famed Ripcurls are packed pizzas cooked with Mozzarella cheese and drizzled with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, and Italian seasoning, sliced into pinwheels and baked to perfection. Finish everything off with one of their mouthwatering desserts, like the cheesecake or Reese’s Peanut Butter pie.
Be sure to check their website for current coupons, valid for carryout only.